Idk if I'll laugh or feel bad for op if this thread gets locked
~SPOILERS TILL SEASON 4 part 2 EPISODE 1~
~NOTE:both studios have easily outdone most of the anime out there in terms of visuals and animation and I highly appreciate and respect both but this is about comparing them with each other because this is final season of my fav anime which has been pretty flawless in most things and i would ofcourse point out if i feel drop in quality..)~
its like if a kid used to score 100% everytime but now is suddenly scoring 80% when it matters the most :(~Visuals:~
Before i point out the stuff i dont like .. let me show you what i like:
as you can see character designs/faces while in peaceful or non intense scenes are more detailed.and the age is well shown.
mappa great shots

ofcourse mappa uses more darker and blant colours which i think fits with how dark the show is right now.
and unlike wit, Mappa is too accurate with the mappa which is personally not something i prefer all the time. (not really a complaint here)
mappa has also messed up many character faces that cant be passed of as ageing.

and my biggest problem is how wierd reiner looks , he is too smoothly drawn and his clours are all wrong
and titan eyes are also less detailed

wit looking fine af :https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-X5V3ePkPWl0/XSRKIE9sJZI/AAAAAAAAAjs/WYFGZ2wHjE8ZDqwhsykeTR67SaMagO4PgCKgBGAs/w4096-h2304-c/levi-vs-kenny-
__
~~~
Animation~~~__
MAPPA HAS MORE FLUID ANIMATION BUT LESS DETAILED
WHILE WIT HAS STIFFER CHARACTER MOTIONS (in season 1 2013) BUT CAMERA WORK/ANGLE (viewpoint) OF WIT IS MORE DYNAMIC HENCE MORE IMMERSIVE AND EXHILARATING
AND wit's animation switches to close scenes to add value to emotionally intense moments.
youtube(24yw-5YvIGk)
youtube(FbKtQ-GMBIA)~Wit's SSS tier Animation~
https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/FgSQXwnU0GElnZ3SNgHOiAMb…
https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/FgSQXwnU0GElnZ3SNgHOiOGY…
https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/2dz6EZS_LXve8zZh6qIGWRXJ…
https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/2dz6EZS_LXve8zZh6qIGWV4s…
https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/6ur-oQU86GICt3uuc4-q3zDm…
But the truth is Mappa has already finished making it so nothing can be done about it..
Hoping for some miracle.
DarkGamerA signing out.
btw MAPPA SURE CAN DO BETTER as you can see this in this god-tier ending song visuals by Mappa where colours and animations are a blessing from heaven
youtube(9lnh--ZOPyo)
_~~_
Idk if I'll laugh or feel bad for op if this thread gets locked
I think i animated SnK better
this is sad
but now is suddenly scoring 80% when it matters the most
I see what you did there......
bro no one fucking cares which studio is better just enjoy anime and that's all
have sex
yall still not bored with this sh*t? I mean comparing both studios.
you should point out some bitches
I'm pretty sure Arifumi Imai animated most of the "SSS tier" WIT animations you show here. He is a free lancer and not a member of WIT's staff. Actually most iconic action scenes you can think of from the first three seasons were animated by him.
rip op
Given OP removed themselves from the thread im just gonna lock it. There are plenty of other threads where people discuss the 2
The thread "Studio Wit Or Mappa(Only Attack On Titan)?" and it's comments have been merged into this thread.
You can view the merged thread's body below:
Would Studio Wit Had Done A Better Job At The Final Season Or Do You Think Mappa Surpassed Wit Entirely?
If You Are Just Satisfied With The Latter Studio, Then There's No Need To Comment About It.
ah shit here we go again
Why Is Every Word Capitalized In Your Body Text
IDK
Who cares at this point
~Part one of this season is simply a meme about loving or hating MAPPA at this point. Part two is way better though.~
The studio change makes a lot of difference, mainly on season one where MAPPA(Substitute studio) wanted their own version of AoT instead of continuing all the good decisions Wit(Original Studio) did in the past.
In answer to your question, MAPPA did not surpass Wit in any way, I don't know why people bring this up so often, is it not obvious Wit surpasses MAPPA in most if not all categories? People must have forgotten the rare gem s1 > s3 AoT is, by praising mappa aren't we saying that "they can make as many low-budget like animes they want as long they have an excuse for it"? It's gaming all over again, yah sure who cares about microtransactions if the game is fun ? and then boom. Rip money, rip details, rip new gen games. We should always ask for excellence even if the anime is good. I'm happy that the AoT top 10 is not rigged like other sites.
Extra Comment:
It gives continuation to the story, the animation is decent, the direction could be worst, the Voice Actors are, all the same, new characters and a conclusion to the story, I can't really give you a harsh reason not to watch, if you're really interested in AoT you need to watch this or go read the manga, principally when you have already watched the whole other seasons, that's literally a decade of content being wrapped up. Watch it (Or read it).
Of Course I will prefer Mappa OLD IS GOLD
The thread "Do you think WIT should've continued with AOT final season." and it's comments have been merged into this thread.
You can view the merged thread's body below:
I kinda liked the animation more in,
https://anilist.co/anime/104578/Attack-on-Titan-Season-3-…
(I still can't get the feels & visuals out of my head. WIT did one hell of a job here.)
And after watching the trailer of the new upcoming anime by wit,
https://anilist.co/anime/108357/Vampire-in-the-Garden
Just out of words. Imo they got enough time to make these & why not the final season.
Why are we still discussing about this?
WiT left AoT. Just..... Cope with it. And it's not like AoT is going bad or anything (as far as Anime went).
And while the new WiT Anime looks good, I'm not really hyped about it.
[Removed]
Not really mad but like c'mon? It's been like 2 damn years when MAPPA took over AoT from WiT.
Yeah, it sucks but like... Just move on, ig?
[Removed]
If we just wanna talk about "WiT vs MAPPA", then there are already plenty of threads. You could've just given your opinion there.
But I thought we're also talking about the new WiT Anime so I just gave my opinion on that too.
[Removed]
Wanted to know opinions not give.
What?
How'd you "know" an opinion if nobody "gives" opinion? Word it a little better.
Was it wrong?
Nope. It's just that, you mentioned the upcoming Anime & AoT but you've been only talking about AoT, so I thought it's kinda odd.
They didn't pick Attack on Titan because at the time it was planned to end with the manga, which meant too short deadlines, corona even with all the problems it added, extended Mappa's deadline by a lot.
That said, the real problem is that unlike Mappa, WIT does not compromise into unhealthy deadlines.